Scholarly Commons

An electronic repository for the intellectual products of the Miami University community

Dare to compare: fact-based versus simulation-based comparison in daily life

DSpace/Manakin Repository

Show simple item record Summerville, Amy en_US Roese, Neal J. en_US 2011-02-07T21:16:35Z en_US 2013-07-10T15:09:40Z 2011-02-07T21:16:35Z en_US 2013-07-10T15:09:40Z 2011-02-07 en_US
dc.identifier.citation Journal of Experimental Social Psychology (2008), 44, 664-671. en_US
dc.identifier.uri en_US
dc.description.abstract We examined the relative frequency of social, counter factual, past-temporal, and future-temporal comparison in daily life using an experience-sampling method, in which participants were randomly prompted to record thought samples using palmtop computers carried for two weeks. Comparative thought accounted for 12% of all thoughts, and all four comparison types occurred with equivalent frequency. Comparisons may be either fact-based (i.e., based on actuality, as in social and past-temporal comparison) or simulation-based (i.e., based on imagination, as in counterfactual and future-temporal comparison). Because the latter are more “unbounded,” and because greater perceived opportunity invites greater self-improvement, we predicted and found that counterfactual and future-temporal comparison were more likely to be upward (vs. downward) than social and past-temporal comparison. All comparison types focused on approach more than avoidance motives, except for counterfactuals, which showed equivalent focus on both. These findings reveal the prominence of comparative thought in daily life, and underscore the value an integrative theory that describes social, counter factual, or temporal comparison using a common theoretical platform. en_US
dc.subject approach en_US
dc.subject avoidance en_US
dc.subject counterfactual en_US
dc.subject affect en_US
dc.subject motivation en_US
dc.subject regret en_US
dc.subject social comparison en_US
dc.subject temporal comparison en_US
dc.title Dare to compare: fact-based versus simulation-based comparison in daily life en_US
dc.type Text en_US 2008 en_US
dc.type.genre Article en_US

Files in this item

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record

Search SC

Advanced Search


My Account